A Blind Mencia Tasting

Gathered around a few white cloth-covered tables under brighter than usual Saturday night lights, I hosted a group of 17 New England tasters to evaluate a dozen wines made from the Mencia grape.  Finally, the opportunity to examine Mencia in a critical environment presented itself and I looked forward to validating my developed preference that I have unleashed on restaurant wine lists across the country.

Having never met a Mencia wine I didn’t like, I wondered what might happen in a blind, varietal peer group format.  We assessed a decent range of wines from vintages spanning 2003-2008 sourced from the Valdeorras, Bierzo, and Ribeira Sacra growing regions in Northwest Spain.  The wines ranged from 12%-14% alcohol content and retail price points started at $12 (2005 Flavium Crianza) moving all the way up to $80 (2007 El Pecado).  The event confirmed what I was discovering piecemeal trying these wines one at a time accompanied with food; strutting its stuff without attempts to hide anything, Mencia displays a combination of red/blackberry fruit, exotic and herbal aromas, rustic characteristics, and a richness that never feels too ripe.  On this evening, the wines seemed to organize themselves into two broad categories; (1) rustic earthiness combined with exotic, spicy aromas (2) deep fruit core with berry flavors and floral aromas relegating rustic, garrigue hints to the background.

Before a lineup rundown and some words on the group’s favorites, it’s worth remembering that this grape is indigenous to these Northwest regions of Spain and not grown anywhere else.  There was a school of thought that the grape was related to Cabernet Franc, but the speculation has been suffocated by negative DNA tests.  As we gathered around our glassware, a friend and fairly steady tasting partner, Glen, reminded us that he has visited his son-in-law’s family who hails from these parts, and not to forget that Ribeira Sacra and Valdeorras (getting famous for the delicious white wines made from Godello fruit) are part of Galicia while Bierzo, 70 miles to the east of Ribeira Sacra, buts up against the same unique environmental influences that the Galician ocean and mountains offer.  The vineyards are found in both valley floor and terraced hillsides, with soils of stone and clay down below and granite and schist composition up top.  The wines are products of their home, and I noticed a few wines, including the overwhelming crowd favorites, moved toward a riper international market style, slightly departing from the brighter berry and herbal terroir driven qualities of the hills and ocean influences that Glen’s son-in-law is also a product of.  These few wines, while delicious, seemed to lose some of the tell-tale berry characteristics we were discovering through the evening.

Here are the wines we tasted and some approximate retail prices:

2003 Ribas Del Cua, Bierzo $20

2003 Tilenus, Bierzo $25

2005 Baltos, Bierzo $15

2005 Flavium Crianza, Bierzo $12

2006 El Castro de Valtuille, Bierzo  $16

2007 Losada, Bierzo $20

2007 Vina Caneiro, Ribeira Sacra $28

2007 El Pecado, Ribeira Sacra  $80

2007 Petalos, Bierzo $25

2007 El Cayado, Bierzo $20

2008 Pena do Lobo, Ribeira Sacra $17

Bodega Jesus Nazareno as Chas, Valdeorras  $13

Jay Miller at the Wine Advocate reviewed nine of these twelve wines and gave all of them 90+ scores.  He rated the El Pecado 98 points, saying:

Its ethereal aromas are reminiscent of a great vintage of La Tache (readers will surely think I’m exaggerating) leading to a layered, sleek, elegant wine with tons of spice, that seems to melt in the mouth.

The extraordinary wines of Raul Perez must be tasted to be believed. Words simply cannot do them justice. The problem is that they are produced in minuscule quantities.

Interestingly, the El Pecado did not finish in the top 3 of the group’s favorites.  It was fifth.  I was surprised.  It showed its dark black color, was restrained in its ripeness, had deep black cherry flavors with a little pepper spice, tobacco leaf on the nose, and a sweet long finish.  It was in the evening’s first flight, and was my third favorite of that flight and fifth favorite overall.  Yet, the notes were consistent with the first time I tried this wine at Casa Mono (which you can read about in this post) when I sang its praise;

…intense aromas of rich black fruit, raspberries, and earth with other stuff I could not even recognize in the nose.  Tasting this wine with dishes like bone marrow, fideos with chorizo and clams, pumpkin and goat cheese croquetas, crispy pork belly with apple salad, and duck egg with mojama (salt cured tuna) created a competition for aroma definition that had my nose raising white flags of surrender.  But, the intensity of the wine was something I had not experienced in a very long time…pure elegant fruit, laser point focus, and the silkiest mouthfeel imaginable for a wine as packed as this.  And the finish…wow that finish…..went on for minutes and the depth of flavors and fruit hung in there with rich blackberry, spice and earth filling my head and chest….I thought of some of the great Paulliacs I’ve tasted in classic vintages where gobs and layers of fruit packed elegantly into silk purses of soft supporting tannins, all with finishes to remember.

The group’s, and my own, favorite was the 2007 Losada.  I loved this wine the first time I tried it at Toro, in Boston’s South End, which concluded in a search and destroy mission that had a dozen bottles land in my cellar.  On this evening, the wine showed its unusually dark black/purple color and meaty gamey aromas.  Amanda, one of our tasters and budding wine writer, discovered exotic barbeque duck spice and someone else reported tar-like flavors.  In past tastings of this wine I also noted cinnamon and fruit cake aromas.  The wine’s finish, as usual, was long and rich.

The least favorite wine of the night was from the cooperative of Bodega Jesus Nazareno; as Chas. Lightest in color of all the wines we tasted, it exhibited a barnyard, animal, manure smell that actually appealed to me, but repulsed a lot of the other tasters.  I turned my head to the wine’s lack of fruit and middle depth.  The wine was not horrible, but it was not in the same league as the others.  It might be nice to drink with some barbequed pork or heavily herbed salmon.  Not to be totally dismissed, it was the only wine that generated any real objection.  As such, all the wines in the lineup are recommended and represent, for the most part, strong values.

Taking second place was the 2003 Tilenus.  It was good to see one of the wines with a little bottle age perform well.  It was black in color with sweet floral perfume, tobacco leaf, garrigue and lead pencil aromas.  Interestingly, the center of the the wine was in need of just a bit more fruit,  leaving me a little surprised and expecting lots more considering its intense aromatics.

A wine that did not place in the group’s top three, but was my second favorite of the first flight of six wines was the El Castro de Valtuille.  A rich purple color with amazingly true Mencia character shining through, the wine had red berry crossing into strawberry and pomegranate seed aromas, sweet flower petals combining with a slight mustiness, and rich red and blackberry fruit flavors in the finish.   The wine is multidimensional and constantly changed in the glass showing its kaleidoscope character.  It did secure a few 1st place votes by the group.

Third on the group’s overall list was the other 2003, Ribas del Cua.  The color of the wine was deep purple, with tar and cigar wrapper on the nose.  Deep black cherry flavors dominated.

Worth noting in my top 5 was the Vina Caneiro from Ribeira Sacra.  The color was light purple with an alluring bright black cherry, cola, Pinot Noir-like nose.  The 07 Vina Caneiro delivered a rich fully coated mouthfeel, with one of the longest, velvet-like finishes of all the wines we tasted.

With the tasting accomplished, I was restfully satisfied that these wines are for real and worth buying.   Wines with seven years of bottle age were showing well, there was a definite varietal streak that carried through all the various styles, and even when modern wine making gets introduced, the resulting wines are released with acceptable alcohol levels and restraint allowing for true recognition and enjoyment of the region’s special terroir.   I still love Mencia, even after the battery of tests we put it through this evening.

  • Thomas Matthews

    Nice exposition of an intriguing wine. I have not tasted all the wines in this flight, so can’t comment on your rankings, but your description of Mencia’s varietal character rings true to me. Of the wines I have rated, I particularly liked the El Castro de Valtuille, and find the Petalos a consistent winner.

    Thomas Matthews
    Executive editor
    Wine Spectator

  • http://winezag.wordpress.com adamjapko

    Tom,

    Thanks for weighing in on the Mencia tasting recap. I concur with you on the Petalos. I have had the wine many times and it is a real favorite of mine..I was surprised it did not rise to the very top of the tasting results. I suspect having a few older wines in the lineup tilted an otherwise even playing field. It is fully recommended.

    Adam

  • lynda

    It was a great night and we all learned alot about this intersting variety. Next time I’ll have my own wine glasses!

  • Pingback: Tweets that mention A Blind Mencia Tasting « WineZag -- Topsy.com

  • kitos george

    Very good exposition.You burnd my mind with your coments.I hope my Mencia wine also taste like all theese wines. I planted the privious year about 1500 mencia vines in central greece and now I have about 1500 botlles maturing in knew barells.I hope to be an intresting experiment to see how the Greek terroir will impact on a Spanish variety.